The insurance industry is undergoing a transformative shift, shaped by competitive pressures, increased capital availability, and an evolving business landscape—partly catalyzed by the COVID-19 pandemic. These changes have pushed independent insurance agents (IAs) to seek new strategies to thrive and maintain their independence in an increasingly competitive market. One such strategy has been joining agency networks, which offer a range of benefits that are often harder to achieve as standalone entities. Understanding the motivations behind this shift and the role these networks play in the insurance distribution ecosystem is crucial for carriers looking to make strategic decisions.
The Competitive Pressures Pushing Agencies to Seek Networks
Despite predictions to the contrary, the role of the insurance agent remains significant. For the past two decades, much attention has been given to the rise of direct and alternative distribution channels, such as embedded insurance in the purchase processes of vehicles or point-of-sale offerings. However, the notion of the agent’s “death” has been greatly exaggerated. In fact, IAs continue to dominate in commercial lines and remain a key player in the overall insurance distribution landscape.
Several factors have contributed to the sustained relevance of IAs, including the complexity of risks and exposures in a rapidly evolving world, which increases the need for human expertise. As commercial risks grow in complexity due to new business models, technologies, and a changing regulatory environment, the role of agents becomes even more critical.
The insurance industry has also seen increased competition and capital availability, even in the face of rising interest rates. The availability of capital, driven by private equity investments, has fueled a wave of mergers and acquisitions within the agency space. Private equity firms are increasingly consolidating smaller agencies, creating larger entities that have the resources to scale and compete more effectively. Despite the economic challenges presented by interest rate hikes, the pipeline for mergers and acquisitions (M&A) remains strong, as capital is still accessible for well-positioned agencies. This has created both opportunities and pressures for IAs, especially smaller ones, to consider joining networks in order to stay competitive.
The Evolving Work Environment and Its Impact on IAs
The post-pandemic world has introduced a hybrid work environment that requires new capabilities from insurance agencies. The ability to operate virtually and retain top talent has become a critical requirement for survival. Unfortunately, many smaller agencies lack the infrastructure and skills to transition smoothly into this new work paradigm. This is where agency networks provide a solution, offering technological and operational support that enables smaller agencies to adapt to the new normal.
The talent crunch is another major issue facing the industry. Despite the rise of alternative staffing models like gig workers and virtual teams, many IAs are struggling to secure and retain the necessary talent. The average age of insurance producers and account managers exceeds 50, signaling a potential talent shortage as more employees approach retirement age. Younger professionals are not entering the insurance workforce at a rate sufficient to replace those leaving, exacerbating the talent gap.
Moreover, digital transformation is now a necessity for IAs. Today’s consumers expect insurance agencies to be “open for business” across all channels, including digital platforms. Having a robust online presence is no longer optional but essential for prospecting, customer engagement, and retention. Many IAs, particularly smaller ones, lack the expertise and resources to build and maintain a competitive digital marketing strategy, further motivating them to seek assistance from agency networks.
Agency Networks: Leveling the Playing Field
In response to these challenges, agency networks have become a vital lifeline for independent agencies. By joining a network, IAs gain access to resources and capabilities that would otherwise be out of reach. These include marketing support, training, technology, and access to enhanced compensation structures. Networks often pool the premiums of member agencies, enabling them to meet the entry gates for increased base and variable compensation from carriers. This structure allows smaller agencies to compete more effectively with larger players, such as agency roll-ups and larger brokerage firms.
For exclusive agents (EAs), who typically have access to fewer carriers and less operational flexibility, agency networks offer a compelling alternative. By joining a network, EAs can enjoy the best of both worlds: the freedom to work with multiple carriers and the operational support needed to scale their business. This model has become especially attractive to historical EA talent, which is increasingly moving toward independent agency models, bolstering the pool of viable IAs.
The rise in the popularity of agency networks is evident in the numbers. According to recent data, the United States had nearly 40,000 independent agencies as of 2022, an increase of 4,000 from 2020. Over two-thirds of these agencies generate less than $500,000 in revenue, making them prime candidates for network membership. In fact, more than 70% of IAs in the U.S. are part of one of the roughly 150 available networks. The benefits provided by these networks, particularly in addressing the skill, scale, scope, and capital challenges faced by small to mid-sized agencies, have made them an essential part of the insurance ecosystem.
The Cost for Carriers: Navigating the Impact of Networks
While the rise of agency networks has generally been a boon for IAs, it presents a more complex picture for carriers. Engaging with networks requires carriers to balance the costs and benefits of this growing distribution model. On the one hand, networks provide access to a large, aggregated group of agencies, offering economies of scale in distribution. On the other hand, the growing power of networks can drive up the total cost of distribution.
Carriers must also consider the impact of network membership on agency loyalty and behavior. IAs that are part of a network may have more negotiating power, potentially driving down commission rates or demanding more favorable terms. Additionally, carriers may find it more challenging to differentiate themselves in a networked environment where agencies have access to multiple carriers and can more easily switch between them.
Understanding why IAs join networks is key for carriers to develop effective engagement strategies. The common misconception is that agencies join networks solely for increased revenue. While revenue is certainly a factor, it is not the only driver. Agency networks offer numerous other benefits, such as operational support, access to technology, and marketing expertise, all of which help agencies address the challenges they face in today’s competitive landscape.
The Key Challenges Driving Agencies to Join Networks
The decision to join a network is often influenced by a combination of factors, many of which stem from the operational and financial pressures faced by smaller agencies. These challenges can be grouped into four key dimensions:
- Skill: The skill sets needed to manage an agency (e.g., administration, compliance) often come at the expense of the skills needed to grow the business (e.g., sales, digital marketing). Many agencies also struggle to keep up with the tech skills required to operate in today’s digital-first environment.
- Scale: Smaller agencies often lack the scale needed to attract and retain talent or to leverage better deals with carriers. Being part of a network can help agencies achieve economies of scale and improve their negotiating position.
- Scope: While one of the core strengths of IAs is their ability to offer a wide range of products, smaller agencies may lack the capacity to fully understand the breadth of products and brands available. A limited employee base means they often rely on a generalist model, rather than having specialized roles that can provide deeper expertise.
- Capital: Investing in the tools and capabilities needed to differentiate an agency requires significant capital, which is often out of reach for smaller firms. By joining a network, agencies can access these resources without having to make the upfront investment themselves.
The Future: How Carriers Should Respond
As agency networks continue to grow, carriers must evolve their strategies to engage effectively with this distribution structure. This may involve developing new partnerships with networks, offering enhanced technology platforms and data analytics to help agencies thrive, or rethinking compensation models to account for the unique dynamics of networked agencies.
Carriers that successfully navigate the rise of agency networks will be those that can offer value beyond just financial compensation. This includes providing educational resources, marketing support, and operational tools that help IAs succeed in a complex and evolving marketplace.
In conclusion, the rise of agency networks represents a significant shift in the insurance distribution landscape. While the trend offers numerous benefits to IAs, it also presents challenges for carriers. By understanding the motivations driving agencies to join networks and responding with innovative solutions, carriers can position themselves for success in this new era of insurance distribution.
1 thought on “The New Landscape of Insurance Distribution”